I am a professional reminder-er and permission granter who moonlights as an artist, author, professional speaker, and publisher of The Adultitis Fighter, which helps people create lives filled with adventure, meaning, and joy. I enjoy Star Wars, soft t-shirts, and brand new tubes of paint. My wife Kim and I homeschool our three weird kids and live in Wisconsin, where we eat way too many cheese curds.
Share
"Half-Full or Half-Empty?" is the Wrong Question ☕️
Greetings from Sheboygan, where we just sent out my newest Mini*Print and its story to Collector Club members. If you want to bring a little more wonder into your home—and give Adultitis one less place to hide, join us!
Forget about liberal and conservative; if you really want to stir the pot, call someone a pessimist.
I recently shared the benefits of being optimistic, and the response it generated was fascinating. I enjoyed these creative takes:
“The glass is always full… don’t forget about the air inside.”
“Not only is the glass half-empty; it’s the wrong beverage!!”
“It doesn’t matter if the glass is half-full or half-empty; the glass is refillable.”
And then there’s this one from an engineer: “A pessimist sees the container as half-empty; an optimist sees it as half-full. An engineer sees that the container is twice the size that is needed.”
It turns out that the labels “optimism” and “pessimism” are like the concept of “life balance” — everyone has a different definition of what it looks like, and a strong opinion of whether it’s possible at all.
No one likes to admit they are a pessimist. So they call themselves realists instead. In my experience, self-proclaimed “realists” are quite good at telling you why something might not work, but less effective at sharing examples of how it might go better than expected.
To be fair, I’ve always been suspicious of people who seem almost too optimistic, in the Lego Movie’s “Everything is Awesome” sort of way. A vital component of creativity is the ability to look for problems, then work to find positive solutions.
The hidden danger of optimism is letting your assumption that everything will work out prevent you from trying to get better. On the other hand, pessimism feels like a synonym for Adultitis, so I can see the vitriol against it as a label.
So let’s put labels aside in favor of a few things that are really real:
“Optimist” and “idiot” are not synonyms.
Being an optimist does not preclude one from identifying weaknesses and potential roadblocks.
Seeing a flaw in a plan or identifying a reason why something might not work doesn’t make you a pessimist.
It is not “realistic” to assume a plan will work out without any hiccups, setbacks, or wrong turns.
It’s also not “realistic” to assume there will only be hiccups, setbacks, and wrong turns.
We should all strive to be realists. But a true realist would acknowledge that things might go worse than we hoped, and they may also go better than expected. Failing to imagine a successful outcome or a better way forward is a lack of hope and a form of pride, believing one can see all possible scenarios.
It’s easy to get lost in the weeds, arguing over labels and definitions, and justifying why our point of view is best. Most importantly, whether you label your worldview as optimistic, pessimistic, or realistic…is it helping?
Is it moving you forward, or getting you to stop?
When optimism becomes a form of laziness that believes everything will be fine without you having to put in any effort whatsoever, that’s a problem.
Equally troublesome is when pessimism turns you into not just someone who sees the glass half empty, but a person who gives up and encourages others to give up, too.
Worst of all is giving ourselves the label “realist” to sound smart while providing cover for throwing in the towel.
Screw the labels. Here’s the question that matters: what do you do when you uncover a reason your plan might not work or encounter a setback that threatens defeat?
What then?
If you stop, that’s a problem.
Is it half full, or half empty? Our default tendency to assume the best or the worst in a given situation might be out of our control.
But that matters less than whether we let it make us stop or keep moving forward.
Don’t make being realistic the same as giving up.
When was a time you refused to give up and transformed a setback or a potential pitfall into a win? Share your thoughts with me, join the conversation in The Wonderground, or spend time this week recording them in your journal.
Stay young and stay fun,
P.S.
What do I do when a painting should be finished, but I don't love it? This Studio Sneak Peek shares an approach I took this week. (You can also watch it on Facebook, YouTube, or TikTok.)
Join The Collector Club! 💌
Part art collection, part inspiration, and part monthly reminder of what matters most. We'd love to send a little surprise and delight your way each month.
As low as $20/month • Shipping included • Cancel anytime
On a mission to help people break free from Adultitis to build better lives, businesses, and teams.
I am a professional reminder-er and permission granter who moonlights as an artist, author, professional speaker, and publisher of The Adultitis Fighter, which helps people create lives filled with adventure, meaning, and joy. I enjoy Star Wars, soft t-shirts, and brand new tubes of paint. My wife Kim and I homeschool our three weird kids and live in Wisconsin, where we eat way too many cheese curds.
View online • Get this from a friend? Subscribe here! Shenanigating Since 2000 | 2026 Issue #39 🙃 Happy Sunday, Reader! Greetings from Sheboygan, where we are thrilled with the early response for the 2027 Celebrate Everything Calendar. BIG thanks to everyone who has supported us with their order! Today is a great day to secure yours, as the price goes up $1 tomorrow, and each day until we close reservations on October 31. This week, I've got a new installment of Echo Base Dispatch, the video...
View online • Get this from a friend? Subscribe here! Shenanigating Since 2000 | 2026 Special Issue 📅 Happy Thursday, Reader! The Great Calendar Experiment is officially open! Reserve your 2027 Celebrate Everything Calendar today for just $15—half the regular $30 price. A whole year of colorful art, uplifting stories, and excuses to celebrate? Sounds like a pretty good antidote to Adultitis. Here’s how this year’s experiment works: Today is the best deal. Tomorrow, the price becomes $16. It...
View online • Get this from a friend? Subscribe here! Shenanigating Since 2000 | 2026 Special Issue 💌 Happy Wednesday, Reader! I wanted to remind you that we're doing something different this year with the 2027 Celebrate Everything Calendar. First, we START taking orders tomorrow. And we'll STOP taking orders on October 31. At that point, reservations close, and we send our order to the printer. The pricing is also unusual. The regular price is $30. But tomorrow, it's on sale for just $15. On...